Podcast · Ep25
5 Questions to Help Decide How to Niche

Five questions to help you decide how to niche, from who you serve and why to whether it scales profitably, so you avoid the costly mistakes of niching badly.
There's a lot of advice out there about the need to niche, so you might wonder what this can teach you that you haven't heard already. I'm going to skip the general stuff and look at the problems that come from not focusing on your niche in the right way.
The common perception is that niching is about who your target market is and what you sell them, and I can see why people stop there. On Dragons' Den, someone walks in nervous, with sweaty palms, and pitches an idea to the five dragons. Through the edit, you only see the top level, and none of the detail that makes them different or investable.
I see so many people make mistakes when they niche, or stay too generalist, that I wanted to help you avoid the traps. They cost you revenue, profit and time. You might take just one nugget from these five questions, and it might be the difference between getting this right and getting it wrong.
Question 1: Who Is Your Market?
Everybody talks about this one. Knowing who you're marketing to lets you sharpen your messages, so people can look at what you're about and say, "Yes, that's me," or, "No, that's definitely not me."
A Physio in the North-East
One client who brought this to life for me is a physio who runs four practices in the north-east of England. His patients pay privately, in a historically lower-income area where most people would wait on an NHS list.
At a high level, his niche is people in their 50s and 60s who want to stay as active as they were in their 20s, 30s and 40s. Go a step further, and they don't want to wait on NHS lists for a service that might only go so far towards getting their full mobility back.
They love running, golf or riding a bike they've spent a few thousand pounds on. They've seen friends wait for NHS treatment and never come back to the thing they enjoyed. So there's a time aspect, because they want a solution quickly, and a financial one, because they're prepared to pay for results. They'll also follow a programme that addresses the cause of their pain.
When he chose that focus, I'm sure part of him worried about cutting out patients he'd lose to someone else. What it's let him do is speak to specific needs in his marketing, such as the fear of missing out and being able to enjoy their pursuits whenever they want.
A B2B Example
Another client does communications training in professional services, and works especially well with legal practices. Go further, and her best clients tend to be underrepresented groups whose voices aren't heard in boardrooms and meetings. That might be women, people with disabilities, people returning to work or people with autism. They're great at what they do, and sometimes can't make themselves heard because their backgrounds, where they went to school or their interests differ from the core management team's.
Dial in again and you reach the owners of those firms, who lose out when that expertise isn't heard.
Everybody will tell you they work in a niche, whether that's e-commerce, plumbers or another industry. There are always three or four more levels of detail you can explore to hone in on the who, without compromising your chance of finding a market.
Question 2: Why Does This Market Have a Problem?
Question two mirrors question one, and many people never ask it. If you don't answer it, you miss the purpose of how you serve that audience.
Is the problem expensive for them, or time-consuming? What's the complete pain in the bum for that group, and why can't they solve it themselves? Think about what you can do almost in your sleep, after years of building your expertise. The who and the why go together, and answering one strengthens the other.
Question 3: What Are You Providing?
The third is another common one: what product or service are you providing? Because you're good in your domain, you can go down multiple rabbit holes, doing lots of general work that spreads you thinly. Across several clients, all that context switching is a huge drain on your energy, and you won't achieve the outcomes you'd like for as many clients.
So look for the deep areas of expert skill that solve the biggest pains in the bum for your audience. You might be able to do X, Y and Z, and find that Z adds most value.
How I Found My Own What
I've worked in the CRM, email marketing and sales funnel space for 14 years, and it took me a couple of years to see that one of my deep skills is joining up processes in businesses. That's what the eight LEMONADE steps do, from leads through to endorsements.
Within that, I'm very good at helping clients whose own clients take a long time to decide. Back to the physio, many of his patients put off booking because they think the pain might go away, as it has before. With my guidance, his marketing sends a gentle drip of tips, insights and past patient examples. Whether a patient takes a month, eight months or two years to decide, the marketing keeps reaching them for as long as they need.
If someone is slow to decide and you stop following up, by the time they're ready the trail has gone cold. They start their own research again and end up working with someone else. Keeping that lead warm is one of my areas of expertise, and I discovered it when clients told me they'd never thought about things in quite that way.
Stuff for Your People
In episode 20 I quoted Allan Dib, author of The 1-Page Marketing Plan and Lean Marketing. He says most small businesses come up with a product and then go looking for buyers, when it should be the other way round. Research your market's pain points, perhaps by working with clients, and shape your products for those people. He calls it "stuff for your people, not people for your stuff", and it makes a lot of sense when you're deciding your what.
Question 4: Is It Scalable and Profitable?
Just as the who and the why mirror each other, so do questions three and four. Alongside your product or service, ask whether it's scalable and whether it's profitable.
Two Ways to Scale
The first angle is whether you can deliver it in a wider setting, without your time limiting it. Could you run it for a group instead of one-to-one, turn it into a course, or create an asset you can sell without needing to be there? That scales without a team or associates.
The second angle, if you can't, is whether you can bring in staff on payroll at a salary that still lets you deliver profitably.
The Garden Designer
One of my clients is a garden designer who loves helping people turn the land behind their house into a beautiful garden they enjoy spending time in. Transforming a blank or overgrown plot into something that changes how a family thinks about their home brings her a lot of joy.
An end-to-end garden design takes a ton of energy and back and forth, with clients who hesitate or change their minds about what to include. That limits how many clients she can take on. She didn't want to give up helping clients shape their gardens, and she did need to scale without recruiting.
Her route was to design certain garden types and borders that work in a number of settings, so people could achieve, say, 80% of their objective without hiring her one-to-one. She sells that online with very little interaction or ongoing management. It frees up time and energy, and the online revenue gives her freedom, flexibility and a financial buffer.
Don't Buy Yourself a Job
There's a great book on scalability by John Warrillow, who I've mentioned before on the podcast, called The Automatic Customer. Its subscription and recurring revenue models could each benefit a small business.
Scalability might come from recurring revenue, a group format where one hour does the work of five, systems that run automatically, or a model where you can hire help profitably. If you have none of those and only ever work one-to-one, you're in effect buying yourself a job, back doing the work as you would if someone employed you.
Question 5: Do Your Clients Share Your Values?
The final question, values alignment, is a much softer one, and it's something you'll probably refine over time. You don't need your personal values written down, although that can help. A gut feel can be good enough, and if you can show it on your website, so much the better.
Learn From Past Clients
If you struggle to pin down your values, look back at past clients or patients. Who paid late? Who asked for things you hadn't agreed to deliver? Were some rude, or even aggressive, in a way that felt out of line? Did they say thank you, or acknowledge that a question might be disturbing you? All of those shape your judgement of what's important to you.
What Matters to Me
I enjoy working with clients who value their own clients, who don't profiteer from their clients' problems, and who are passionate about fair value and great service. Family, my clients, ongoing learning and an ethical, valuable service all matter to me, and those traits are common in my clients.
When I talk about volunteering and coaching kids' football, they'll have examples of volunteering in their own communities. When I talk about prioritising time with my family, some will have similar stories. I share tips online, and my clients often do the same.
“We're an ethics-driven type of community. We care about the people that we serve, and the reason we care about them is because there's a joy to helping others.”
Questions for You to Consider
- Could you describe your ideal client three or four levels deeper than their industry?
- Why can't your market solve their problem on their own?
- Which one or two of your skills add the most value to your clients?
- Could you deliver your core service in a group, a course or a product?
- If you hired help, could you still deliver profitably?
- Which past clients paid late, asked for extras or were rude, and what does that tell you about your values?
Take Aways to Action
- Go three levels deeper. Write down your market's age, motivation, timescale and willingness to pay, beyond their industry.
- Answer the why. Note what makes the problem expensive or time-consuming, and why they can't fix it themselves.
- Pick your Z. Choose the one or two skills that add most value and lead with them.
- Test for scale. Sketch one way to deliver your service without your time, or with profitable staff.
- Name your values. List the traits of your best and worst past clients and reflect them on your website.
Timecodes
Time | Topic |
|---|---|
00:00 | Mistakes when you niche, or don't |
01:02 | Niching goes deeper than the who and the what |
01:32 | The Dragons' Den view of niching |
02:33 | Why getting it wrong is costly |
03:04 | Question 1: who is your market? |
03:34 | The physio in the north-east |
06:10 | Time, money and commitment |
07:14 | What focusing let him do |
08:16 | A B2B example in communications training |
10:18 | Three or four levels deeper |
10:49 | Question 2: why does this market have a problem? |
12:56 | Question 3: what are you providing? |
14:59 | How I found my own what |
16:32 | Keeping a lead warm for as long as it takes |
18:03 | Allan Dib: stuff for your people |
19:36 | Question 4: is it scalable and profitable? |
20:39 | Hiring staff profitably |
21:10 | The garden designer |
24:16 | John Warrillow's The Automatic Customer |
24:49 | Buying yourself a job |
25:54 | Question 5: values alignment |
26:56 | Learning from past clients |
27:58 | The values I look for in clients |
30:01 | The cost of generalist work |
32:04 | Niching opens more doors |
Filed underStrategy

