Podcast · Ep47
Why Your Marketing Reaches Only 2% of Buyers

Only around 2% of people who find you are ready to buy, yet most experts market only to them. Meet the four business owners in LEMONADE Plan and see why.
LEMONADE Plan pulls into one place many of the stories, experiences and guidance I've gathered over the last 12 or 13 years, from something like 400 client implementations with small businesses like yours. I wanted it to be a book you could read in two or three hours.
In the last episode I explained why I've written it. This one covers what you can expect when you read it, and one of the key themes that runs through it: the gap between how most expert businesses market themselves and what the people discovering them are ready for.
What LEMONADE Plan Is About
The LEMONADE methodology, as I've come to call it over the last few years, runs from the first L, leads, through to the final E, endorsements, meaning reviews, referrals and repeat sales. The book is about systemising those eight key processes, so you can make more sustainable profits and get reviews systematically.
You Need Both Profits and Reviews
Without one there isn't the other. If we can't run a profitable business, we don't stay in business. If we aren't getting the recognition our efforts and our quality deserve, the cycle that lets the business keep growing is unlikely to continue.
Four Business Owners Like You
The book follows four business owners as they systemise their businesses. They're very similar to yours or mine, and you can draw on their examples to improve the eight processes in your own.
Sarah, the Business Coach
Sarah faces the challenge many experts have when they guide their own clients: the cobbler's children's shoes. She's great at guiding her clients, but when it comes to her own business and operations, some of the processes and systems are lacking.
Michael, the Physiotherapist
Michael is a great expert in physiotherapy, and his patients love the results they get from him. His challenge is running his business in a more automated way, so he can step back from the day-to-day admin and work with more patients or on building the business. He needs operations scalable enough to remove himself from the equation.
James, the Heating Engineer
James works in a B2C setting, with clients in their own homes, delivering solutions that are often complex and different each time. He runs a multi-van business, and his question is how to make the quality of his quotes and his work scalable across his growing team. Along the way he realises that some of what he's doing is great, and in other areas his competitors have a bit of a lead.
Emma, the Virtual Assistant
Virtual assistants are great at taking on the tasks of the businesses they work with, but they aren't always so good at standardising those processes across clients. That's the big challenge Emma confronts in the story.
A Playbook at the End of Every Chapter
You don't have to be a business coach, a physio, a heating engineer or a VA to translate these stories into your own world. The book is written so you can see how they overcome their challenges and ask the same questions of your own business. At the end of every chapter there's a playbook-style section where you can make notes and put your thoughts into play.
Why I Came Up With LEMONADE
Over years of helping clients one to one, I'd seen my clients get certain things working well, but with gaps and patches between process steps that should have been interconnected. Those gaps meant what they delivered was unprofitable, unsustainable or unable to grow, or that when client and patient relationships ended, the positive feedback their efforts deserved didn't come.
These little cliff-drop moments across the eight process steps were being missed. LEMONADE came into being to address those cliff-drops and make sure all eight customer stages are joined together and interconnected.
If your delivery model feels a little unsustainable, or clients reach the end of working with you without leaving reviews or sending referrals, there's probably something in the book for you.
Most Marketing Speaks to Only 2% of Buyers
One of the key themes in LEMONADE Plan is the misalignment of expectations that people meet when they first discover your business. It's about understanding what stage of buying someone is at when they find you or explore what you share on your website, socials or emails. I call these stages TOFU, MOFU and BOFU, and if you're a regular listener you'll probably be rolling your eyes that I'm back on them, but they matter.
The Curse of Expertise
Most service businesses, where you're paid for your expertise, face a curse of expertise problem. When somebody discovers us, we half expect them to know what they're looking for and how to buy, so all we need to do is have the sales discussion.
The widely quoted figure is that only 2% of the people who discover you are currently ready to buy. If you position all of your content around getting someone to book a sales appointment or buy from you, you're probably forgetting the other 98% of the market, the people in research mode.
“Only 2% of people that discover you are currently in buying mode.”
The 98% Still Researching
Those people are at one of two earlier stages. At the top of the funnel, they're looking for more insight into the problems they have. In the middle of the funnel, they're fully aware of those problems and what causes them, and they're researching a solution.
Most expert businesses that sell anything of real value miss the chance to nurture that interest, because their content doesn't speak to people at the top or middle of the funnel. That means missing a whole chunk of prospective clients, patients or customers somewhere down the line. There are untapped riches in great follow-up marketing, and the four business owners in LEMONADE Plan discover where their gaps are and how to market to these buyers more effectively. If you'd like a refresher on the three stages, The 3 Stages of the Sales Funnel covers them in more detail.
In the next episode, I take you through another key concept of LEMONADE Plan, having a system for success. It looks at one of the big failings of expert businesses in their marketing and sales strategy, and one in the small business coaching market.
Questions for You to Consider
- Which of the four business owners in the book is closest to your own situation?
- Where are the gaps between your eight process steps, from leads to endorsements?
- What share of your content asks people to book a call or buy?
- What do you offer someone who is still trying to understand their problem?
- What do you offer someone who understands their problem and is researching solutions?
- How do you follow up with people who discover you but aren't ready to buy yet?
- Do your client relationships end with reviews and referrals, or with silence?
Take Aways to Action
- Aim for both outcomes. Treat predictable profits and systematic reviews as the two things your business needs to survive.
- Find your cliff-drops. Look for the gaps between process steps where clients or profit fall away.
- Write for the 98%. Create content for people at the top and middle of the funnel, as well as those ready to buy.
- Follow up on interest. Build follow-up marketing that nurtures people who aren't in buying mode yet.
- Standardise your delivery. Make your quotes and processes consistent so your quality scales with your team.
Timecodes
Time | Topic |
|---|---|
00:30 | What to expect from LEMONADE Plan |
01:00 | 13 years and around 400 client implementations in one book |
01:31 | Eight processes from leads to endorsements |
02:41 | Four business owners and their stories |
03:13 | Sarah, the business coach |
03:44 | Michael, the physiotherapist |
04:17 | James, the heating engineer |
05:18 | Emma, the virtual assistant |
05:49 | A playbook at the end of every chapter |
06:49 | Why I came up with LEMONADE |
07:50 | Joining up the cliff-drop moments |
08:51 | Misaligned expectations and TOFU, MOFU and BOFU |
09:53 | Only 2% of people are in buying mode |
10:24 | The 98% in research mode |
11:29 | Untapped riches in follow-up marketing |
12:02 | Next episode: a system for success |
Filed underEducation

